Manual therapy interventions for the foot and ankle have been associated with improvements in pain and function in individuals with ankle sprains, plantar heel pain (PHP), cuboid syndrome (CS), and symptomatic hallux abducto valgus (HAV)
Ankle Sprain:
To date, there have no placebo-controlled trials that explore the long-term effectiveness of manual therapy interventions on disability and function for individuals status-post (s/p) lateral ankle sprain. Several studies have shown manual therapy to be effective in improving dorsiflexion range of motion, a common impairment found in individuals s/p ankle sprain.
Green et al. investigated the effect of talo-crural posterior glide mobilizations on dorsiflexion range of motion and 3 gait variables in individuals s/p lateral ankle sprain. Patients receiving talocrural mobilizations in addition to a program of rest, ice, compression and elevation (RICE) demonstrated greater improvements in stride speed and required fewer visits to achieve full, pain-free dorsiflexion range of motion than subjects receiving RICE alone.
Whitman and colleagues developed a clinical prediction rule (CPR) to identify individuals s/p inversion ankle sprain likely to demonstrate a rapid and dramatic response to a management program that included manual therapy interventions and general mobility exercises. Five variables were identified as predictors and together formed the CPR. The variables were:
1. Patient report of symptoms worsening with standing
2. Patient report of symptoms worsening in the evening
3. A navicular drop test greater/equal to 5 mm
4. Distal tibiofibular joint hypomobility
The CPR demonstrated a positive likelihood ratio of 5.9, indicating that individuals who were positive for at least three of the four variables increased their likelihood of a successful outcome with this management strategy from 75% (pre-test probability) to 95% (post-test probability). This CPR must be further tested in a broader patient population with a comparison group and long-term follow up in order to validate the findings of this preliminary study.
Plantar Heel Pain (php):
Supportive evidence for the role of manual therapy in the management of PHP has been limited, but preliminary evidence has been promising. Cleland et al. compared the effectiveness of two distinct rehabilitative programs for individuals with a diagnosis of PHP. One group received six sessions of ultrasound and iontophoresis (with dexamethasone) treatment as well as a home exercise program of calf stretching and foot intrinsic muslce strengthening exercises. The second group received six sessions of manual therapy interventions directed primarily at the ankle and foot. Treating clinicians in the manual therapy group were also free to treat other joints in the spine and lower quarter as they deemed necessary based on a thorough clinical exam. Subjects receiving manual therapy also performed a home exercise program of calf stretching and soft tissue mobilization of the plantar fascia. At the four week follow up, both groups demonstrated improvements in clinical outcomes, however, individuals receiving manual therapy interventions showed greater improvements in pain, function and disability compared to the group receiving electrophysical agents. These differences were clinically meaningful and were largely maintained at the 6 month follow up.
Young and colleagues reported clinical outcomes in a case series of four subjects with PHP following seven or fewer treatment sessions of manual therapy interventions to the ankle and foot combined with therapeutic exercise. All subjects demonstrated clinically meaningful improvements in pain function.
Cuboid Syndrome (cs):
Cuboid syndrome is also known as “subluxed cuboid”, “dropped cuboid”, “cuboid fault syndrome” and “lateral plantar neuritis”. There have not been any controlled-trials comparing the relative effectiveness of interventions for CS to date. Jennings et al. conducted an observational case-series of seven subjects diagnosed with CS following lateral ankle sprain. All subjects were treated with a “cuboid-whip” manipulation followed by 1 minute of soft-tissue massage to the plantar aspect of the foot. Two of the subjects required repeat manipulations, while the other five subjects only required one treatment. All subjects had complete and long-term resolution of symptoms immediately following treatment.
- Jennings, 2005, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
- du Plessis, 2011, Foot
- van der Wees, 2006, Aust J Physiother
- Hoch, 2010, J Sport Rehabil
- Wong, 2010, N Am J Sports Phys Ther
- Hoch, 2010, J Sport Rehabil
- Hensley, 2011, Manual Therapy
- Hoch, 2011, J Orthop Res
Other Relevant Evidence:
- Lopez-Rodriquez, 2007, J Manipulative Physiol Ther
- Landrum, 2008, J Man Manip Ther
- Fujii, 2010, Manual Therapy
- Grindstaff, 2011, J Electomyogr Kinesiol
- Yeo, 2011, Manual Therapy
